| The Team |
| Offense |
Defense |
| QB - Logan Weaver (Indiana, Sr.) |
DL - Joe Price (Purchase Line, Jr.) |
| RB - Andrew Iezzi (Blairsville, Sr.) |
DL - John Blankenship (United, Sr.) |
| RB - Dom Chero (United, Sr.) |
DL - Mark Ebberts (Ligonier Valley, Sr.) |
| RB - Joey Vodopivec (Penns Manor, Sr.) |
DL - Stefan Moreau (United, Sr.) |
| WR - Tyrall Veney (Indiana, Sr.) |
LB - Alex Atkins (Northern Cambria, Jr.) |
| WR - Taylor Ferguson (Blairsville, Sr.) |
LB - Cody Wood (Marion Center, Sr.) |
| TE - Cory Brown (Penns Manor, Jr.) |
LB - Adam Torrance (Ligonier Valley, Sr.) |
| OL - Kasey Jewart (Penns Manor, Jr.) |
LB - Nick LaMantia (Marion Center, Sr.) |
| OL - Chris Bracken (Penns Manor, Sr.) |
DB - Alex Pettina (Indiana, Sr.) |
| OL - Alex Tripodis (Blairsville, Jr.) |
DB - Mike Cavazza (Marion Center, Sr.) |
| OL - Bryce Ritenour (Ligonier Valley, Sr.) |
DB - Adam Polites (Northern Cambria, Jr.) |
| OL - Justin Spencer (Indiana, Jr.) |
Punter - Mike Newhouse (Homer-Center, So.) |
| Kicker - Dane Mossgrove (Indiana, Sr.) |
Coach - Bill Packer, Penns Manor Comets |
| The 2011 Renda All-Star Football Team was selected by a vote of Renda Broadcasting game broadcasters and area coaches. |